The Big Question: Should You Renovate or Move?

Mark Hewitson • November 12, 2021

Renovate or Move?

The last 18 months changed what many buyers are looking for in a home. Recently, the American Institute of Architects released their AIA Home Design Trends Survey results for Q3 2021. The survey reveals the following:

  • 70% of respondents want more outdoor living space
  • 69% of respondents want a home office (48% wanted multiple offices)
  • 46% of respondents want a multi-function room/flexible space
  • 42% of respondents want an au pair/in-law suite
  • 39% of respondents want an exercise room/yoga space


If you’re a homeowner who wants to add any of the above, you have two options: renovate your current house or buy a home that already has the spaces you desire. The decision you make could be determined by factors like:

  • A possible desire to relocate
  • The difference in the cost of a renovation versus a purchase


Finding an existing home or designing a new home that has exactly what you want (versus trying to restructure the layout of your current house)


In either case, you’ll need access to capital: the funds for the renovation or the down payment your next home would require. The great news is that the money you need probably already exists in your current home in the form of equity.


Home Equity Is Skyrocketing

The record-setting increases in home prices over the last two years dramatically improved homeowners’ equity. The graph below uses data from CoreLogic to show the average home equity gain in the first quarter of the last nine years:The Big Question: Should You Renovate or Move? | MyKCMOdeta Kushi, Deputy Chief Economist at First American, quantifies the amount of equity homeowners gained recently:


“Remember U.S. households own nearly $35 trillion in owner-occupied real estate, just over $11 trillion in debt, and the remaining ~$24 trillion in equity. In inflation adjusted terms, homeowners in Q2 had an average of $280,000 in equity- a historic high.”


As a homeowner, the money you need to purchase the perfect home or renovate your current house may be right at your fingertips. However, waiting to make your decision may increase the cost of tapping that equity.


If you decide to renovate, you’ll need to refinance (or take out an equity loan) to access the equity. If you decide to move instead and use your equity as a down payment, you’ll still need to mortgage the remaining difference between the down payment and the cost of your next home.


Mortgage rates are forecast to increase over the next year. Waiting to leverage your equity will probably mean you’ll pay more to do so. According to the latest data from the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), almost 57% of current mortgage holders have a mortgage rate of 4% or below. If you’re one of those homeowners, you can keep your mortgage rate under 4% by doing it now. If you’re one of the 43% of homeowners with a mortgage rate over 4%, you may be able to do a cash-out refinance or buy a more expensive home without significantly increasing your monthly payment.


First Step: Determine the Amount of Equity in Your Home


If you’re ready to either redesign your current house or find an existing or newly constructed home that has everything you want, the first thing you need to do is determine how much equity you have in your current home. To do that, you’ll need two things:

  • The current mortgage balance on your home
  • The current value of your home


You can probably find the mortgage balance on your monthly mortgage statement. To find the current market value of your house, you can pay several hundreds of dollars for an appraisal, or you can contact a local real estate professional who will be able to present to you, at no charge, a professional equity assessment report.


Bottom Line


If the past 18 months have refocused your thoughts on what you want from your house, now may be the time to either renovate or make a move to the perfect home


Start by finding out what your home should sell for.  Use our FREE Custom home value - Comparative Market Analysis (CMA).  We'll create a FREE Custom CMA, not some computerized "guess-ti-mate" created by a robot on these national sites.  Go to www.MDHomesValue.com today, we'll create your CMA for you in 48 hours.  No Pressure, no obligation, no committment.  Just solid info.

Maryland Real Estate Professionals Real Estate Outlook

By Mark Hewitson April 2, 2025
5 ROADBLOCKS TO AFFORDABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP (AND WAYS TO MOVE PAST THEM)
By Mark Hewitson March 2, 2025
Tax season. Just the words can send shivers down your spine.
By Mark Hewitson February 3, 2025
Ask any homeowner about what they would like to change about their home, and most will say, “How much time do you have?
By Mark Hewitson January 4, 2025
The 2025 Real Estate Report
By Mark Hewitson December 2, 2024
The holidays are a time for joy, family, and celebration!
By Mark Hewitson November 21, 2024
You need our 4 proven strategies
By Mark Hewitson November 3, 2024
How to Find a Home That Fits Your Whole Family

By Mark Hewitson October 1, 2024
Stage to Sell: 7 Proven Steps to Attract Buyers and Boost Offers 
By Mark Hewitson September 4, 2024
One of the most critical decisions you'll make is choosing the right contractor
By Mark Hewitson August 4, 2024
Top 4 Factors to Consider When Choosing Your Mortgage
More Posts